Understanding the Interaction Between Dorsal Vagal and Sympathetic States

1. Traditional Model:

   • Dorsal vagal activation is often associated with parasympathetic dominance → freeze, collapse, dissociation.
   • Sympathetic activation is associated with fight-flight → hyperarousal, action, agitation.

2. Reality: These systems do not always operate in a binary way.

   • The dorsal vagus can coexist with sympathetic activation, leading to shutdown with agitation, a state seen in trauma, borderline states, and some psychopathic presentations.
   • The ventral vagus (social engagement system) is what normally modulates between these two extremes, but in trauma states, it's often underdeveloped or bypassed.

---

How Dorsal & Sympathetic Activation Can Coexist

💡 Think of the dorsal vagus as having two possible expressions:

1. Classic Dorsal (Passive Freeze → Total Collapse)

   • Parasympathetic dominant, low energy.
   • Flat affect, numbness, low muscle tone.
   • Seen in schizoid withdrawal, deep shame collapse, dissociation.

2. High-Sympathetic, Low-Ventral (Active Freeze → Rigid, Defensive)

   • Sympathetic & dorsal vagal co-activation.
   • Person appears tense, controlled, "frozen in readiness" rather than limp.
   • Seen in psychopathic rigidity, narcissistic injury, trauma hypervigilance.

---

Personality Structures & Their Dorsal-Sympathetic Interactions

Structure	Autonomic State Under Stress	Dorsal Component?	Sympathetic Component?
Oral	Collapse into abandonment despair	✅ Full dorsal (numb, uncontained)	❌ Minimal
Masochistic	Suppressed energy, but internal fight	✅ Partial dorsal (inhibited)	✅ Bursts of sympathetic (frustration, resentment)
Narcissistic	Grandiosity → Shame collapse	✅ Dorsal (shame crash)	✅ Sympathetic (defensiveness, rage)
Psychopathic	Tension, control, aggression	✅ Low-dorsal (blunted emotions, numbed empathy)	✅ High-sympathetic (dominance, fight mode)
Schizoid	Detachment, depersonalization	✅ Full dorsal (complete retreat)	❌ Minimal

---

Examples of High-Sympathetic, Low-Ventral States

1. Psychopathic → "Rigid Freeze"

   • Not limp like full dorsal shutdown, but also not fluidly engaged.
   • Feels tense, calculating, predatory rather than relaxed.
   • Body is armored, stiff, breath held shallowly (low ventral tone, but high sympathetic readiness).

2. Narcissistic → "Shame Collapse After Rage"

   • Starts high sympathetic (fight mode) → Then crashes into dorsal (shame, withdrawal).
   • Example: Someone explodes in anger, then disappears for days in emotional shutdown.

3. Masochistic → "Suppressed Fight"

   • Appears calm but has internalized tension.
   • Low external action, but internal frustration burns in muscles.

---

Key Takeaways

• Dorsal vagal activation is not always "floppy" collapse—it can also be rigid and frozen if mixed with sympathetic activation.
• When dorsal and sympathetic are active together, it creates a "stuck" state—tense, dissociated, or aggressive but disconnected from emotion.
• The missing piece in these defenses is often ventral vagal regulation, which allows fluid movement between activation and relaxation.